Best Shotgun to Buy at Every Budget (2026 Guide)
Shotguns are the most versatile firearms you can own — home defense, hunting, clays, and competition all with one gun. Here are the best picks at every budget with real prices from r/gundeals.
Quick Answer by Budget
| Budget | Pick | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Under $250 | Maverick 88 | Budget home defense, first shotgun |
| $270–$500 | Remington 870 Police Trade-In | Best value used pump |
| $300–$500 | Mossberg 500 / 590 | All-around pump, HD + hunting |
| $400–$600 | Benelli Nova / SuperNova | Best pump action made, period |
| $600–$900 | Beretta A300 Ultima | Best value semi-auto, clays + hunting |
| $1,200–$1,400 | Beretta 1301 Comp | Fast semi-auto, competition + HD |
| $1,600–$2,000 | Benelli M4 | The gold standard, military proven |
Best Budget Shotgun: Maverick 88 ($180–$230)
The Maverick 88 is made by Mossberg (same factory, same barrel, same action) with a few cost-saving changes: cross-bolt safety instead of tang safety, and a pinned forend. That's it. It goes bang every time and costs less than a nice dinner for two. With an average of 150 upvotes per deal on r/gundeals, it's one of the most popular shotgun deals posted — people get genuinely excited when these drop under $200.
The Maverick 88 is also a top pick for home defense on a budget. Load it with buckshot and you have a reliable HD setup for under $250 total.
Best All-Around Pump: Mossberg 500 / 590 ($350–$550)
The Mossberg 500 has been the American pump shotgun for decades. Tang safety (ambidextrous), dual action bars, and compatibility with a massive aftermarket. The 590 is the tactical version with a heavier barrel, bayonet lug, and metal trigger guard/safety.
590 vs 590A1: The 590A1 has a heavier barrel, metal trigger guard, and metal safety button. It's the military spec version (MIL-SPEC 3443) — the same shotgun issued to U.S. armed forces. Worth the extra $50-100 if you plan to run it hard. With 17 deals averaging 85 upvotes on r/gundeals, the 590/590A1 is consistently one of the most posted tactical shotguns.
The 590A1 is a top choice for home defense — pair it with a weapon light and you're set. Track prices: Mossberg 500
Best Pump Made: Benelli Nova / SuperNova ($400–$600)
The Benelli Nova is the smoothest-cycling pump action on the market. One-piece receiver/stock design makes it incredibly strong and ergonomic. The SuperNova adds a removable stock and ghost ring sights option.
What to Pay for a Benelli Nova
- Great deal: Under $380
- Good deal: $380–$450
- Average: $450–$530
Track it: Benelli Nova price history
Best Value Semi-Auto: Beretta A300 Ultima ($600–$800)
The Beretta A300 Ultima is THE most posted shotgun on r/gundeals — 46 deals averaging 121 upvotes. That's not an accident. Gas-operated, soft-shooting, and reliable with everything from light target loads to heavy buckshot. It's the gateway to semi-auto shotguns and dominates sporting clays courses. If you're looking for a do-everything semi-auto, this is it.
The A300 is an excellent choice for hunting — it cycles everything from light dove loads to 3" magnums. Also check out the home defense guide if you want to run it for HD.
Best Tactical Semi-Auto: Beretta 1301 Comp ($1,100–$1,400)
The Beretta 1301 is the fastest cycling semi-auto shotgun in production — 36% faster than the competition according to Beretta. With 23 deals averaging 99 upvotes on r/gundeals, it's the go-to premium semi-auto for both competition and home defense. Dominant in 3-gun, and increasingly the recommended HD shotgun for people who want semi-auto reliability without Benelli M4 money.
The 1301 Tactical is a top-tier home defense semi-auto. If you're into competition shooting, it also pairs well with a pistol caliber carbine for multi-gun matches.
The Gold Standard: Benelli M4 ($1,600–$1,900)
The Benelli M4 is the shotgun the U.S. Marines chose (designated M1014, winning the Joint Service Combat Shotgun program). Its dual gas/inertia ARGO system is one of the most reliable semi-auto actions ever designed — it runs everything from light birdshot to full-power slugs without adjustment. Only 5 deals posted on r/gundeals but averaging a massive 183 upvotes each — when an M4 deal drops, the community goes wild.
The M4 is the ultimate home defense shotgun if budget isn't a constraint. It's overkill for hunting — this is a fighting shotgun, period.
Honorable Mention: Remington 870 Police Trade-Ins ($270–$650)
The Remington 870 Police trade-ins are some of the best value pump shotguns you'll find. These are duty guns that departments are replacing — they've been maintained, they work, and they cost a fraction of new price. With 11 deals averaging 85 upvotes on r/gundeals, the community consistently recommends these when they pop up.
Buyer's tip: Look for ones with ghost ring sights and extended magazine tubes — those are the real Police models, not Express guns. Cosmetic wear is fine; these are built to last decades.
Pump vs Semi-Auto: Which Should You Buy?
- Pump — Simpler, cheaper, runs any ammo. Best for: budget home defense, hunting, beginners.
- Semi-Auto — Faster follow-up shots, less felt recoil. Best for: clays, competition, home defense if budget allows.
For a deeper breakdown on setting up a shotgun for home defense, check our Best Home Defense Setup guide. Heading into the field? See our Best Hunting Setup guide.
Track Shotgun Prices
Related Guides
- Best Home Defense Setup — shotgun HD configurations, ammo, and accessories
- Best Hunting Setup — field shotguns, optics, and load recommendations
- Best Pistol Caliber Carbine — another great HD and competition option
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Shotgun?
There is no single "best" — the right pick depends on use case and budget. We rank candidates by tracked deal frequency, lowest verified price, and dealer-reputation rate to surface the ones that consistently show up at real-deal prices.
How much should I expect to pay for Shotgun?
Pricing varies by model and condition. Use our price-distribution chart for the specific item you are considering — it shows great-deal, good-deal, and average thresholds based on real r/gundeals posts.
How do I know I am getting a real deal on Shotgun?
Compare the listed price against tracked-average data on r/gundeals. Below the great-deal threshold, the price is rare and worth acting on. Above the average, set a free price alert and wait for a real drop.
Where do most Shotgun deals come from?
Across tracked r/gundeals deals, dealer rotation matters — some dealers consistently post sub-average pricing while others rarely do. Our dealer ratings rank retailers by how often their deals get community medals.
Get deal alerts for products in this guide
Share this guide
Never overpay again
We track every deal on r/gundeals. Set free price alerts for any product.
Browse Products & Set Alerts