Last updated June 10, 2026
Benelli M4 vs Remington 870
Real price comparison based on 33 tracked r/gundeals deals.
Bottom line
Cheaper historically: Benelli M4 at $40.
Lower average: Remington 870 at $309.
More deals tracked: Remington 870 (17 vs 16).
Set alerts on both — Benelli M4 · Remington 870.
Side-by-side
| Metric | Benelli M4 | Remington 870 |
|---|---|---|
| Historical low | $40 | $100 |
| Tracked average | $1251 | $309 |
| Median price | $1649 | $300 |
| Highest tracked | $1949 | $650 |
| Real-deal threshold | < $1188 | < $294 |
| Steal threshold | < $1063 | < $263 |
| Deals tracked | 16 | 17 |
3 cheapest Benelli M4 deals
-
[Acc] $40 Benelli M4, SBE, Stoeger Compatible Aimpoint …$40Feb 08, 2026 · rustynutsdesigns.com
-
[parts] Benelli LE M4 7 shot magazine tube - $89$89Mar 24, 2025 · midwestgunworks.com
-
[Acc] Benelli M4 Telescoping Stock Assembly (70085) - $…$250Mar 05, 2026 · botach.com
3 cheapest Remington 870 deals
-
[Acc] Police Trade-In Remington 870 Wood Stock & Forend…$100May 01, 2025 · wistransfers.com
- $120
-
[Shotgun]Police Trade-in Remington 870 12 GA 18" Extend…$270Apr 09, 2025 · kingsfirearmsonline.com
Track both. Buy whichever drops first.
Free email alert when Benelli M4 or Remington 870 drops below your target.
Frequently Asked Questions
Benelli M4 or Remington 870 — which is cheaper?
Historically, the Benelli M4 has the lower floor at $40. By average, Remington 870 wins at $309.
Which has more deals available?
Remington 870 appears more often in r/gundeals deals (17 vs 16).
Should I get the Benelli M4 or the Remington 870?
Set free alerts on both. Pick whichever drops to its real-deal threshold first that matches your use case.
About the editor
GDA Editorial Team · Editorial team, GunDeal Alerts
We track every priced post on r/gundeals, fingerprint products, and verify dealer reputations. This page is updated as new deal data arrives.